The short answer
Writing a longer policy will not fix this. The fix is making the policy, the product page and the ad agree with each other, and then removing the one or two clauses that make a first-time buyer close the tab.
Almost every problem below is a ten-minute edit. None of them needs a developer, and none of them needs a lawyer unless the gap is a missing page entirely.
Pattern one: the page that exists but says nothing
One brand’s shipping policy page carries its heading and nothing underneath. No charge, no timeline, no courier, no contact. Meanwhile the homepage marquee promises SHIPS WITHIN 24H and FREE SHIPPING.
A customer who does the responsible thing — reads the policy before paying — lands on a blank page. The brand has spent money to bring that person to the site and then answered their most basic question with an empty screen.
This is worse than having no page, because a missing page is at least honest. An empty page tells the buyer the shop does not maintain its own terms.
Pattern two: the contradiction
One streetwear label’s FAQ says orders are dispatched within 24 hours. Its shipping policy, one click away, says 1–3 business days. Both sentences are on the same site, both written by the same team.
A buyer reading both will hold the brand to the faster promise, and then complain when it does not arrive. The complaint is not the customer being difficult. It is the shop having promised two different things.
The fix here is not to pick the faster number. It is to pick the one you can actually hit on your worst week, and then use that same number everywhere — FAQ, policy page, product page, ad, and the automated order email.
Pattern three: the threshold nobody clears
One streetwear brand sets free shipping at Rs 5,000. Its t-shirts are Rs 2,500, its caps Rs 2,000, its hoodie Rs 4,500, its Oxford shirt Rs 3,500. Thirteen of its fifteen products do not clear the threshold on their own, and every one of them pays Rs 200 in shipping.
That is eight percent on a Rs 2,500 tee — a fee that appears at the last step of checkout, after the customer has already decided to buy.
A free-shipping threshold is not a margin lever. It is a nudge, and it only works in the direction you point it. Set above your average order value, it stops nudging and starts charging the people who were only buying one thing to try you out. The customer who was already going to spend Rs 6,000 did not need the incentive. The customer buying one tee did.
Pattern four: the offer that removes your return right
One brand’s returns page says all sales are final — no returns, no refunds, no store credit — with a single size exchange allowed within four days. The same policy then excludes promotional items from that exchange.
The brand’s own creator collaboration runs a discount code for Rs 500 off.
So the buyer who arrives through the ad the brand is paying for is the one buyer who cannot exchange the size. Every other customer keeps a narrow right; the one the marketing budget was spent on loses it.
Another brand in the set has a cleaner version of the same trap. Its refund policy offers no exchange at all: the customer must return the unopened item and then, in the policy’s own words, make a completely separate purchase for the one they wanted. The exchange section is where the shop asks for a second buying decision.
What a shipping page actually needs
Six things, and all six fit on one screen.
| What | Why it is there |
|---|---|
| Dispatch window | The number you can hit in a bad week, not a good one |
| Delivery estimate | Split by metro and rest-of-India if your courier differs |
| Shipping charge | Exact figure, and the threshold if there is one |
| Courier | Named, so the buyer knows what to expect at the door |
| Damage window | How many hours to report a damaged parcel, and to whom |
| Contact | A real address a human reads, with the hours it is read |
If any one of those is missing, the buyer fills the gap with the worst assumption available to them. That is how a shop with a perfectly good operation ends up looking unreliable.
The returns language that costs you the sale
Three clauses recur across the storefronts I read, and each one costs something specific.
“All sales final.” This removes the last piece of risk from a first-time buyer’s decision. On a Rs 500 product it is a shrug. On a Rs 4,500 jacket it is the reason the cart is abandoned.
Store credit only, no refund to the original payment method. Defensible for a small brand protecting cash flow, but it changes what the customer is buying. They are no longer buying a garment; they are buying a garment plus a future obligation to spend again at the same shop. Say so on the product page, not three clicks deep.
A short expiry on that credit. One brand issues store credit valid for three months. Another gives 180 days. The customer who forgets is a customer who has paid you and received nothing, which is the worst possible outcome for a brand that needs repeat purchase to survive.
How to check your own in ten minutes
Open three things side by side on a phone: your homepage, your shipping policy page, and any product page.
Read the dispatch promise on the homepage. Now find the same promise in the policy. If the two sentences disagree, you have found the cheapest fix on this list.
Next, add your cheapest product to the cart and go to checkout. Watch what appears. If a shipping charge shows up that the product page never mentioned, the buyer is finding out at the worst possible moment.
Finally, read your own returns page as if you were a customer who has just received a jacket that does not fit. Ask one question: what happens to my money? If the honest answer is “it becomes store credit I have to spend here again”, that is a real term and it is allowed — but it belongs on the product page, before the decision, not after it.
Ten minutes. No developer, no agency, no new tools. Most of what this article describes would have been caught by that walk-through.
What I would fix first
- Open your own shipping and returns pages on a phone. If either is empty, write it today. It is the cheapest fix on this list.
- Put your real dispatch window in one place and copy that exact phrase to the FAQ, the policy page and every product page.
- Check your free-shipping threshold against your cheapest product. If the cheapest thing you sell cannot clear it alone, the threshold is charging your newest customers.
- Read your discount terms against your returns terms. If a promo code removes the exchange right, either drop that clause or stop running the code.
- Add a damage window with a named email address. Forty-eight hours and one address converts a complaint into a replacement instead of a chargeback.
What I did not check
I did not place an order on any of these storefronts, so I have not tested checkout, packaging, courier performance or the post-purchase emails. I read what each shop publishes, not what it does. Where a brand’s site sat behind bot protection, I verified the page in a real browser render rather than a text fetch — a text fetcher will report a false 404 on a page that is live.
Questions this article answers
What is the most common mistake on Indian D2C shipping pages?
A policy that contradicts the homepage. One storefront promises dispatch within 24 hours on its FAQ and 1–3 business days on its shipping policy. Both sentences sit on the same site.
Should a free-shipping threshold be above or below the average order value?
Below. A threshold above the average order value stops working as a nudge and starts charging shipping to the customers buying one item to try the brand. One streetwear label sets it at Rs 5,000, so thirteen of its fifteen products pay Rs 200 in shipping on their own.
Is a returns policy legally required for an Indian D2C brand?
Not as a standalone policy. India’s Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020 require an inventory e-commerce entity to display accurate information about return, refund, exchange, warranty, delivery and shipment terms. The National Consumer Helpline states that a returns policy is preferable but not separately mandated by law. What is mandated is that whatever terms apply are stated accurately and prominently, before purchase.
